Welcome to

Buttercup Bakery

Freshly baked cookies, made with love to bring sweetness to every celebration.

HANDMADE

Every cookie is rolled, cut, baked, and decorated by hand. No shortcuts—just careful craft in every detail.

FRESH & SWEET

Baked to order with quality ingredients and finished with smooth royal icing for that perfect bite.

TRADITIONAL

Our signature sugar cookies are timeless and tender, designed to delight guests of all ages.

MADE WITH LOVE

Custom colors, themes, and messages—thoughtfully designed to make your moments unforgettable.

Original

TRADITION



At Buttercup Bakery, every batch of our gourmet sugar cookies follows a time-honored, handcrafted tradition that brings the warmth of home to every occasion. With a passion for detail and quality, our cookies are made from the freshest ingredients, ensuring that each bite is a sweet reminder of Florida's finest baked goods.

Whether you're celebrating a birthday, wedding, or any special milestone, we create custom designs with care and precision, ensuring your cookies are a true reflection of your unique event.

Our local bakery in Alachua, FL is proud to serve the Gainesville area with fresh, made-to-order treats for every celebration, big or small. Let us bring that extra sparkle to your gathering with the sweet, nostalgic taste of traditional sugar cookies.


Start Your Order

OUR CUSTOMERS LOVE US


 

Buttercup Bakery was absolutely AMAZING to deal with!! I’m not from the same country but she knew what she was doing, and confidently handled my order…she even baked in the middle of a crazy storm!!! My friends received their order today and said the cookies were adorable and DELICIOUS!!! Love this small business, highly recommend!!🤩


Lauren


SPEND THE SWEETEST MOMENTS WITH
BUTTERCUP BAKERY


SHOP NOW